17世紀(ji)(ji),滿洲族(zu)興(xing)起于(yu)白山黑(hei)水之間(jian),建立了后(hou)金(jin)(jin)政權(quan),進(jin)而奪取遼東,動搖了東亞地(di)區以明(ming)帝國(guo)(guo)為(wei)中(zhong)(zhong)心的(de)(de)國(guo)(guo)際(ji)秩序(xu)。后(hou)金(jin)(jin)的(de)(de)東鄰朝(chao)鮮(xian)王(wang)朝(chao)自建國(guo)(guo)以來就(jiu)是明(ming)朝(chao)的(de)(de)藩屬國(guo)(guo),篤信程朱理(li)學,嚴守華夷之辨。16世紀(ji)(ji)末,日(ri)本侵(qin)略朝(chao)鮮(xian)(萬歷(li)朝(chao)鮮(xian)戰(zhan)爭,朝(chao)鮮(xian)稱壬辰(chen)倭亂)之際(ji),因(yin)明(ming)朝(chao)救援朝(chao)鮮(xian)的(de)(de)“再造之恩”而使(shi)明(ming)鮮(xian)關系進(jin)一步密切,因(yin)此在(zai)(zai)后(hou)金(jin)(jin)挑戰(zhan)明(ming)朝(chao)秩序(xu)的(de)(de)過程中(zhong)(zhong)天(tian)然地(di)選擇(ze)站在(zai)(zai)明(ming)朝(chao)一方。萬歷(li)四十七年(1619年,天(tian)命(ming)四年),朝(chao)鮮(xian)出兵1萬余人隨明(ming)軍征討后(hou)金(jin)(jin),結果明(ming)軍在(zai)(zai)薩爾滸戰(zhan)役為(wei)代表的(de)(de)一系列戰(zhan)役中(zhong)(zhong)失敗,朝(chao)鮮(xian)殘兵5000人投(tou)降后(hou)金(jin)(jin)。此后(hou),朝(chao)鮮(xian)國(guo)(guo)王(wang)李琿(光海君(jun))奉行中(zhong)(zhong)立政策,暗中(zhong)(zhong)聯絡后(hou)金(jin)(jin),結果在(zai)(zai)天(tian)啟三年(1623年,天(tian)命(ming)七年)被臣下廢(fei)黜(chu),其廢(fei)位理(li)由中(zhong)(zhong)的(de)(de)一條就(jiu)是“陰(yin)懷貳心,輸款奴夷(指(zhi)后(hou)金(jin)(jin))”。新國(guo)(guo)王(wang)李倧(仁(ren)祖)高(gao)舉“崇明(ming)排金(jin)(jin)”的(de)(de)旗號,標榜(bang)與(yu)明(ming)朝(chao)“協力討虜(lu)”,后(hou)金(jin)(jin)和朝(chao)鮮(xian)的(de)(de)往來一度中(zhong)(zhong)斷(duan)。
不(bu)過,朝(chao)(chao)鮮(xian)(xian)(xian)(xian)(xian)和(he)明(ming)(ming)朝(chao)(chao)未(wei)能真(zhen)正做到同心協力(li)。在(zai)明(ming)(ming)朝(chao)(chao)圍堵后(hou)金(jin)的(de)(de)戰略(lve)布(bu)局中,朝(chao)(chao)鮮(xian)(xian)(xian)(xian)(xian)占(zhan)有重要地位,前遼(liao)東經略(lve)熊廷弼提出“三(san)方布(bu)置策”時(shi),就強調“須聯(lian)合(he)朝(chao)(chao)鮮(xian)(xian)(xian)(xian)(xian)”。明(ming)(ming)朝(chao)(chao)將領毛文(wen)龍(long)在(zai)朝(chao)(chao)鮮(xian)(xian)(xian)(xian)(xian)椵島(皮島)開(kai)辟了反(fan)攻遼(liao)東的(de)(de)基地——東江鎮,朝(chao)(chao)鮮(xian)(xian)(xian)(xian)(xian)雖盡力(li)資助,但內心對其十分(fen)疑忌。結(jie)果朝(chao)(chao)鮮(xian)(xian)(xian)(xian)(xian)和(he)明(ming)(ming)朝(chao)(chao)不(bu)但未(wei)能“協力(li)討虜”,反(fan)而在(zai)天(tian)啟七年(1627年,天(tian)聰元年)后(hou)金(jin)入侵(qin)朝(chao)(chao)鮮(xian)(xian)(xian)(xian)(xian)(丁卯之役)時(shi)不(bu)能有效配合(he),致使朝(chao)(chao)鮮(xian)(xian)(xian)(xian)(xian)被迫與后(hou)金(jin)締結(jie)“兄弟之國(guo)”的(de)(de)盟約(yue),開(kai)放義州中江與后(hou)金(jin)互市,每年向后(hou)金(jin)輸送“歲(sui)幣”。但此后(hou)朝(chao)(chao)鮮(xian)(xian)(xian)(xian)(xian)與后(hou)金(jin)的(de)(de)關(guan)系并不(bu)融洽,兩國(guo)外交(jiao)摩擦集中于(yu)幾下幾個(ge)方面(mian):
俘虜問(wen)題:盡管后(hou)(hou)金(jin)釋(shi)放了(le)丁(ding)卯之(zhi)役中大部(bu)分(fen)朝鮮(xian)被(bei)擄人口,但仍有上萬人被(bei)后(hou)(hou)金(jin)扣作人質,要(yao)求朝鮮(xian)或(huo)以后(hou)(hou)金(jin)逃人交換、或(huo)以米(mi)糧贖回,朝鮮(xian)被(bei)迫選擇后(hou)(hou)者。
逃(tao)人(ren)問(wen)題(ti):丁卯之(zhi)役結束當(dang)年(nian)十二月,皇太極就(jiu)(jiu)指責朝(chao)鮮(xian)不遣(qian)返后(hou)金(jin)(jin)逃(tao)到朝(chao)鮮(xian)的(de)人(ren)員(yuan),朝(chao)鮮(xian)答以逃(tao)人(ren)所剩無幾(ji);崇禎(zhen)四、六年(nian)(1631、1633年(nian),天(tian)聰五、七年(nian)),皇太極兩(liang)度就(jiu)(jiu)逃(tao)人(ren)問(wen)題(ti)向朝(chao)鮮(xian)施壓(ya),朝(chao)鮮(xian)才(cai)遣(qian)返了(le)部分后(hou)金(jin)(jin)逃(tao)人(ren)。
犯(fan)越(yue)問題:丁卯之役后,朝鮮邊民屢(lv)(lv)屢(lv)(lv)越(yue)境(jing)采(cai)參,后金亦侵入(ru)朝鮮境(jing)內屠殺漢人難民,兩國互相指責對(dui)方“犯(fan)越(yue)”,即非法入(ru)境(jing)。
開市(shi)問(wen)題:朝(chao)鮮(xian)自(zi)崇禎元(yuan)年(1628年,天(tian)聰二年)同后(hou)(hou)金(jin)(jin)開市(shi)于義州,但在時間(jian)、價格(ge)、場(chang)所上多有爭(zheng)端,如原(yuan)約為(wei)春秋開市(shi),然而后(hou)(hou)金(jin)(jin)后(hou)(hou)來(lai)又要求(qiu)(qiu)夏季(ji)也(ye)開市(shi),兩(liang)國為(wei)此一(yi)直僵持(chi)(chi);價格(ge)方面(mian)兩(liang)國也(ye)按各自(zi)有利(li)價格(ge)而爭(zheng)論;場(chang)所上,后(hou)(hou)金(jin)(jin)要求(qiu)(qiu)咸鏡(jing)道(dao)會寧(ning)也(ye)開市(shi),朝(chao)鮮(xian)堅持(chi)(chi)拖延不開。
歲(sui)幣問題:后(hou)金(jin)大汗皇太極(ji)嫌(xian)棄朝(chao)鮮的禮物偷(tou)工減料,崇禎四(si)年(nian)(nian)(1631年(nian)(nian),天(tian)聰五年(nian)(nian))朝(chao)鮮在春秋兩次(ci)納歲(sui)幣時,皇太極(ji)都干脆拒絕接受。翌年(nian)(nian),皇太極(ji)派(pai)人通知(zhi)增(zeng)加“歲(sui)幣”種(zhong)類和數(shu)額,仁祖僅同意其新定數(shu)額的十分之一,以金(jin)銀、牛(niu)角、倭劍等不是朝(chao)鮮的特產為由拒絕獻出,其后(hou)兩國互相指責背棄盟約(yue),引發關系緊張(zhang)。
當然(ran),最要(yao)害的(de)問(wen)題在(zai)于朝(chao)(chao)鮮在(zai)明(ming)(ming)(ming)(ming)(ming)金(jin)之(zhi)(zhi)間的(de)曖(ai)昧(mei)關系(xi),即朝(chao)(chao)鮮一面(mian)稱臣明(ming)(ming)(ming)(ming)(ming)朝(chao)(chao)(事大(da)),一面(mian)與明(ming)(ming)(ming)(ming)(ming)的(de)敵國(guo)(guo)后金(jin)修好(交鄰(lin)),這(zhe)種曖(ai)昧(mei)關系(xi)注定不能持久。朝(chao)(chao)鮮在(zai)丁卯之(zhi)(zhi)役后并未斷絕同明(ming)(ming)(ming)(ming)(ming)朝(chao)(chao)的(de)宗藩關系(xi),仍舊遵(zun)奉明(ming)(ming)(ming)(ming)(ming)朝(chao)(chao)正(zheng)朔,年(nian)年(nian)遣(qian)使渡海朝(chao)(chao)貢北(bei)京,明(ming)(ming)(ming)(ming)(ming)朝(chao)(chao)亦不時派遣(qian)敕使來(lai)朝(chao)(chao)鮮。丁卯之(zhi)(zhi)役后第二(er)年(nian),皇太極要(yao)求朝(chao)(chao)鮮提供(gong)船(chuan)(chuan)只以討伐東江鎮,仁祖拖了三(san)天才見后金(jin)使臣,然(ran)后對他們嚴(yan)正(zheng)表示:“明(ming)(ming)(ming)(ming)(ming)國(guo)(guo)猶(you)吾(wu)父也,撫我(wo)二(er)百(bai)余年(nian),今征我(wo)父之(zhi)(zhi)國(guo)(guo),豈可相助(zhu)以船(chuan)(chuan)?船(chuan)(chuan)殆不可借(jie)也!”另一方面(mian),在(zai)明(ming)(ming)(ming)(ming)(ming)軍追擊投奔后金(jin)的(de)吳(wu)橋兵變叛將孔有德、耿(geng)(geng)仲(zhong)明(ming)(ming)(ming)(ming)(ming)等的(de)過程中,朝(chao)(chao)鮮則出兵協助(zhu)明(ming)(ming)(ming)(ming)(ming)軍,令皇太極耿(geng)(geng)耿(geng)(geng)于懷。隨著后金(jin)的(de)日益強大(da),勢(shi)必訴諸戰爭來(lai)解決朝(chao)(chao)鮮懸(xuan)案。
天啟七(qi)年(1627年,天命(ming)十(shi)一年),皇太(tai)極(ji)登上后金(jin)汗(han)位(wei),是為(wei)清太(tai)宗。他(ta)在(zai)位(wei)時,勵精圖治(zhi),實行改革(參見詞條(tiao)皇太(tai)極(ji)新政(zheng)),對內強化(hua)中央集權,樹立起(qi)自己的(de)(de)絕(jue)對權威(wei);對外東征(zheng)西(xi)討,確定(ding)了(le)(le)征(zheng)服明朝(chao)、一統天下的(de)(de)宏(hong)大目標(biao)。從丁卯之役到丙子(zi)之役的(de)(de)十(shi)年時間(jian)里,皇太(tai)極(ji)完(wan)成了(le)(le)幾件大事:一、統一族稱為(wei)滿(man)洲,標(biao)志著一個(ge)新興民族完(wan)成整(zheng)合;二、平定(ding)漠南(nan)蒙(meng)古,西(xi)拓(tuo)疆土(tu);三、三次(ci)入塞侵(qin)略明朝(chao),掠奪大量人口與物資(zi);四(si)、發動(dong)大凌河之戰,取(qu)得重大軍事勝(sheng)利(li),不僅拔(ba)掉(diao)了(le)(le)明朝(chao)在(zai)遼西(xi)的(de)(de)一個(ge)要塞,還獲(huo)得了(le)(le)圍城(cheng)作戰的(de)(de)寶貴經驗。在(zai)這段期間(jian),后金(jin)還有一個(ge)重大的(de)(de)收獲(huo)是孔有德、耿仲明等明將(jiang)攜(xie)紅夷炮(pao)來投,既得到了(le)(le)大量先進武器,又獲(huo)取(qu)了(le)(le)火炮(pao)操(cao)作和瞄準(zhun)技術,并由此開(kai)創出漢人炮(pao)兵與滿(man)蒙(meng)步騎兵協同作戰的(de)(de)戰術。
天(tian)(tian)啟(qi)三年(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(1623年(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian),天(tian)(tian)命八年(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)),李(li)倧通過(guo)宮廷(ting)政變(仁(ren)(ren)祖(zu)反正)登上王(wang)位,是(shi)為朝(chao)(chao)(chao)鮮(xian)(xian)(xian)仁(ren)(ren)祖(zu)。仁(ren)(ren)祖(zu)政權(quan)標榜“崇明排金”,因此(ci)從(cong)一(yi)開始(shi)就將(jiang)防備(bei)后金視(shi)為頭等大(da)(da)事,然(ran)而(er)一(yi)籌莫展(zhan)。當(dang)時(shi),朝(chao)(chao)(chao)鮮(xian)(xian)(xian)兵(bing)(bing)(bing)力(li)嚴重不(bu)足(zu),兵(bing)(bing)(bing)額名義(yi)上為18萬,實則6萬。仁(ren)(ren)祖(zu)即(ji)位后,實施號牌(pai)法,要求16歲(sui)以上男丁(ding)佩戴號牌(pai),加(jia)緊對(dui)人(ren)口(kou)的控制,以擴充(chong)兵(bing)(bing)(bing)力(li)。天(tian)(tian)啟(qi)七(qi)年(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)(1627年(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian),天(tian)(tian)聰元年(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian))號牌(pai)法中止時(shi),朝(chao)(chao)(chao)鮮(xian)(xian)(xian)擁(yong)有(you)兵(bing)(bing)(bing)力(li)約(yue)10萬。此(ci)外(wai)還有(you)“束伍(wu)軍”(類似預備(bei)役(yi))9萬余(yu)人(ren),武(wu)科參(can)加(jia)者(zhe)(zhe)(“出(chu)身”、“武(wu)學”)及雜色軍兵(bing)(bing)(bing)4-5萬人(ren)。但由于朝(chao)(chao)(chao)鮮(xian)(xian)(xian)的社會(hui)生產力(li)在壬(ren)辰倭亂時(shi)遭(zao)到極大(da)(da)破(po)壞,仁(ren)(ren)祖(zu)即(ji)位后仍未恢復(fu),糧餉不(bu)足(zu)也(ye)成為一(yi)大(da)(da)問題,仁(ren)(ren)祖(zu)剛即(ji)位時(shi),戶曹判(pan)書李(li)曙稱朝(chao)(chao)(chao)鮮(xian)(xian)(xian)朝(chao)(chao)(chao)廷(ting)一(yi)年(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)收(shou)入10萬石,而(er)支(zhi)出(chu)11萬石,“經費猶且不(bu)足(zu),有(you)何(he)余(yu)儲以備(bei)軍需?”這種窘況(kuang)到丙(bing)子之役(yi)時(shi)也(ye)沒得到根本性(xing)改(gai)善(shan)。此(ci)外(wai),朝(chao)(chao)(chao)鮮(xian)(xian)(xian)文恬武(wu)嬉,即(ji)使經過(guo)丁(ding)卯之役(yi),依(yi)然(ran)“上下茍安,大(da)(da)官(guan)、小官(guan)悠(you)悠(you)泛泛,諸臣(chen)之會(hui)備(bei)局者(zhe)(zhe),詼諧、吸南草而(er)已,閫帥之倚(yi)轅門者(zhe)(zhe),擁(yong)妓、縱酒肉而(er)已”,意思(si)是(shi)朝(chao)(chao)(chao)鮮(xian)(xian)(xian)上下茍且偷安,大(da)(da)小官(guan)員(yuan)無(wu)所作(zuo)為,備(bei)邊(bian)司重臣(chen)聚在一(yi)起,抽煙打趣,邊(bian)疆將(jiang)帥則整日漁色嫖(piao)妓、喝酒吃肉。仁(ren)(ren)祖(zu)依(yi)賴反正功臣(chen)集團維持政權(quan),放任(ren)反正功臣(chen)欺壓民眾、兼(jian)并土地,朝(chao)(chao)(chao)鮮(xian)(xian)(xian)百姓說:“在廷(ting)權(quan)貴之臣(chen)與(yu)廢(fei)朝(chao)(chao)(chao)(光海(hai)君(jun))異者(zhe)(zhe),只是(shi)面目耳!”朝(chao)(chao)(chao)鮮(xian)(xian)(xian)也(ye)缺乏將(jiang)材,仁(ren)(ren)祖(zu)初年(nian)(nian)(nian)(nian)的都元帥張晚感慨“而(er)武(wu)將(jiang)無(wu)一(yi)人(ren)知(zhi)兵(bing)(bing)(bing)者(zhe)(zhe),只知(zhi)以賂(lu)做(zuo)官(guan)而(er)已”。因此(ci)朝(chao)(chao)(chao)鮮(xian)(xian)(xian)大(da)(da)臣(chen)鄭(zheng)忠信自嘲“無(wu)兵(bing)(bing)(bing)之國”,皇太(tai)極也(ye)常稱朝(chao)(chao)(chao)鮮(xian)(xian)(xian)為“兒女之國”。
在戰(zhan)(zhan)略(lve)(lve)方(fang)針和(he)(he)武器裝備方(fang)面,朝(chao)(chao)鮮(xian)(xian)(xian)自宣(xuan)祖以(yi)(yi)來(lai)就確立了對女真的守(shou)城(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)為(wei)(wei)主、配(pei)以(yi)(yi)火(huo)器的前沿防御(yu)戰(zhan)(zhan)略(lve)(lve)。到了仁祖朝(chao)(chao),由于丁卯之(zhi)(zhi)役時沿路(lu)(lu)(lu)諸(zhu)城(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)相繼(ji)失守(shou),所(suo)以(yi)(yi)戰(zhan)(zhan)后調整為(wei)(wei)讓出大(da)(da)路(lu)(lu)(lu)、修筑山(shan)(shan)(shan)(shan)城(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)、配(pei)以(yi)(yi)火(huo)器的縱深防御(yu)戰(zhan)(zhan)略(lve)(lve),如移(yi)義(yi)州于白馬山(shan)(shan)(shan)(shan)城(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)、移(yi)平(ping)壤于慈母山(shan)(shan)(shan)(shan)城(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)、移(yi)黃州于正方(fang)山(shan)(shan)(shan)(shan)城(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)、移(yi)平(ping)山(shan)(shan)(shan)(shan)于長壽山(shan)(shan)(shan)(shan)城(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng),同時強化江華島(江都)和(he)(he)南漢(han)山(shan)(shan)(shan)(shan)城(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)兩(liang)大(da)(da)要塞的防御(yu)工事(shi)(因漢(han)城(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)較大(da)(da),難以(yi)(yi)防守(shou))。這(zhe)種(zhong)戰(zhan)(zhan)略(lve)(lve)的目的在于堅壁清野、設(she)險守(shou)城(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)、打持久戰(zhan)(zhan),等待(dai)勤王兵(bing)或明(ming)朝(chao)(chao)外(wai)援的到來(lai)或者(zhe)敵(di)軍久攻不下而(er)主動撤退。但皇太極對這(zhe)種(zhong)戰(zhan)(zhan)略(lve)(lve)不屑(xie)一(yi)顧,在開戰(zhan)(zhan)前夕(xi)警告朝(chao)(chao)鮮(xian)(xian)(xian):“貴國(guo)多(duo)筑山(shan)(shan)(shan)(shan)城(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng),我(wo)當從(cong)大(da)(da)路(lu)(lu)(lu)直(zhi)(zhi)向京(jing)(jing)城(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng),其可(ke)以(yi)(yi)山(shan)(shan)(shan)(shan)城(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)(cheng)捍我(wo)乎?貴國(guo)所(suo)恃(shi)者(zhe)江都,我(wo)若蹂躪(lin)八路(lu)(lu)(lu),其可(ke)以(yi)(yi)一(yi)小島為(wei)(wei)國(guo)乎?”此外(wai),朝(chao)(chao)鮮(xian)(xian)(xian)的這(zhe)種(zhong)戰(zhan)(zhan)略(lve)(lve)所(suo)倚靠的是火(huo)器,尤(you)其是鳥(niao)銃,而(er)火(huo)器又依賴從(cong)明(ming)朝(chao)(chao)輸入的硫磺(huang)(huang)、硝石(shi)等原料。崇禎(zhen)五年(1632年,天聰六(liu)年),明(ming)朝(chao)(chao)擔心朝(chao)(chao)鮮(xian)(xian)(xian)資敵(di),遂(sui)對朝(chao)(chao)鮮(xian)(xian)(xian)實施戰(zhan)(zhan)略(lve)(lve)物資禁運,停止(zhi)每年向朝(chao)(chao)鮮(xian)(xian)(xian)例售的3000斤硫磺(huang)(huang)、硝石(shi),給(gei)朝(chao)(chao)鮮(xian)(xian)(xian)造成莫大(da)(da)困難。直(zhi)(zhi)到丙(bing)子之(zhi)(zhi)役爆發前一(yi)天,朝(chao)(chao)鮮(xian)(xian)(xian)派到明(ming)朝(chao)(chao)的最后一(yi)次朝(chao)(chao)天使團(tuan)——金堉為(wei)(wei)首的冬至使,仍在北京(jing)(jing)呼吁解(jie)除(chu)對朝(chao)(chao)鮮(xian)(xian)(xian)的硫磺(huang)(huang)、硝石(shi)之(zhi)(zhi)禁。除(chu)了火(huo)藥(yao)不足,朝(chao)(chao)鮮(xian)(xian)(xian)也缺乏甲衣(yi),都元帥金自點曾說:“我(wo)國(guo)甲衣(yi)極少,遇賊必(bi)敗。”
崇禎八年(nian)(1635年(nian),天(tian)聰(cong)九年(nian)),皇(huang)太(tai)極派(pai)多(duo)爾(er)袞(gun)、岳托、薩哈(ha)廉、豪格等遠征(zheng)察哈(ha)爾(er),蒙古帝(di)國(guo)末代大(da)汗額哲(zhe)投降,標志著(zhu)漠(mo)南蒙古并入后金版圖。額哲(zhe)向(xiang)(xiang)后金獻上(shang)了據稱是(shi)歷代“傳國(guo)玉璽”的印章,后金眾臣便以此為(wei)瑞兆,奏請皇(huang)太(tai)極稱帝(di)。十二月二十八日(ri),經(jing)過群臣再三(san)勸(quan)(quan)進,皇(huang)太(tai)極勉強答應,但(dan)說:“朝鮮乃兄弟之國(guo),應與共議。”時值朝鮮王妃(fei)韓氏(仁烈王后)去世,皇(huang)太(tai)極便派(pai)戶部承政英俄(e)爾(er)岱(朝鮮稱龍骨大(da))和(he)馬福塔(ta)(朝鮮稱馬夫大(da))兩人借春信、吊(diao)祭為(wei)名前往(wang)朝鮮,趁機要求(qiu)朝鮮也參(can)與勸(quan)(quan)進,同行的還(huan)有數十名蒙古貴族,他們代表蒙古向(xiang)(xiang)朝鮮提議勸(quan)(quan)進。
崇(chong)禎九(jiu)年(nian)(1636年(nian),天(tian)聰十(shi)(shi)年(nian))二月二十(shi)(shi)四(si)日,后(hou)(hou)(hou)金使臣(chen)一(yi)行(xing)抵達(da)朝鮮首都漢城,拋出了后(hou)(hou)(hou)金八旗(qi)旗(qi)主及漠南蒙古(gu)四(si)十(shi)(shi)九(jiu)臺吉給(gei)朝鮮國(guo)王(wang)的(de)書(shu)信各一(yi)封,朝鮮官員以(yi)不(bu)合(he)規矩為(wei)(wei)由拒絕受理(兄(xiong)弟之國(guo)的(de)臣(chen)下不(bu)應直接(jie)致書(shu)對方君主)。英(ying)俄(e)爾岱和蒙古(gu)人(ren)(ren)(ren)便(bian)口頭要(yao)求朝鮮為(wei)(wei)皇太極(ji)勸(quan)進。此(ci)言一(yi)出,朝鮮上下嘩然,成(cheng)均(jun)館(guan)儒(ru)生金壽弘率138人(ren)(ren)(ren)聯名(ming)上疏,請求“斬虜使、焚虜書(shu)”。仁(ren)(ren)祖雖不(bu)至于如(ru)此(ci)極(ji)端,但也不(bu)接(jie)見后(hou)(hou)(hou)金使臣(chen)。英(ying)俄(e)爾岱等(deng)人(ren)(ren)(ren)擔心留(liu)在朝鮮有(you)性命之憂(you),趕(gan)緊(jin)搶了朝鮮人(ren)(ren)(ren)的(de)馬匹,奪(duo)門撤(che)走,途中“觀者塞路,群(qun)童或擲瓦以(yi)辱之”。仁(ren)(ren)祖一(yi)面派(pai)人(ren)(ren)(ren)追上英(ying)俄(e)爾岱,遞交答復,表示(shi)后(hou)(hou)(hou)金的(de)要(yao)求是朝鮮“不(bu)敢聞之語(yu)”;一(yi)面于三(san)月一(yi)日向朝鮮八道(dao)下達(da)以(yi)“絕和備御”為(wei)(wei)要(yao)旨的(de)諭書(shu)。英(ying)俄(e)爾岱入(ru)手這些文件(jian),回國(guo)后(hou)(hou)(hou)呈給(gei)皇太極(ji),后(hou)(hou)(hou)金眾臣(chen)建議興師討(tao)伐朝鮮,皇太極(ji)則指示(shi)繼續交涉。
隨后(hou),朝(chao)(chao)(chao)鮮(xian)春信使羅(luo)(luo)德(de)憲、李(li)廓來到盛京,適逢皇(huang)太(tai)極(ji)(ji)于(yu)四月十(shi)一日舉行(xing)登極(ji)(ji)大(da)典(dian),宣布建元(yuan)崇德(de)、國(guo)號大(da)清,羅(luo)(luo)德(de)憲、李(li)廓在大(da)典(dian)上拒絕向皇(huang)太(tai)極(ji)(ji)跪拜,被驅逐出(chu)(chu)境。皇(huang)太(tai)極(ji)(ji)給他們一封國(guo)書,自稱“大(da)清皇(huang)帝(di)”,稱朝(chao)(chao)(chao)鮮(xian)為(wei)“爾國(guo)”,要求朝(chao)(chao)(chao)鮮(xian)國(guo)王立即送(song)子弟為(wei)人質。羅(luo)(luo)、李(li)兩人在進入朝(chao)(chao)(chao)鮮(xian)前(qian)丟(diu)棄該國(guo)書,但謄寫內容(rong)呈給仁祖(zu)。朝(chao)(chao)(chao)鮮(xian)再次(ci)舉國(guo)嘩然。六月十(shi)七日,仁祖(zu)向清朝(chao)(chao)(chao)發出(chu)(chu)“檄書”,強調“敗盟”責任在清方(fang),兩國(guo)關系瀕臨(lin)破裂。
此時皇(huang)太極(ji)尚(shang)未(wei)入侵朝(chao)(chao)鮮,因(yin)為他正(zheng)派軍隊入侵明朝(chao)(chao)(參見詞條丙子之(zhi)變)。十月,征明大(da)軍凱旋,皇(huang)太極(ji)就著(zhu)手籌劃出征朝(chao)(chao)鮮,并派人前(qian)往蒙(meng)古會盟(meng),查戶口、編(bian)牛(niu)錄,抽調外藩蒙(meng)古之(zhi)兵力從征。皇(huang)太極(ji)親征朝(chao)(chao)鮮的目(mu)的,從政治上(shang)來(lai)說(shuo)(shuo),是通過(guo)降服朝(chao)(chao)鮮這(zhe)一“禮(li)義(yi)之(zhi)邦”來(lai)樹立正(zheng)統性,從軍事上(shang)來(lai)說(shuo)(shuo),是解除攻(gong)打明朝(chao)(chao)的后顧之(zhi)憂,從經濟上(shang)來(lai)說(shuo)(shuo),當時清朝(chao)(chao)糧食歉收,皇(huang)太極(ji)希(xi)望通過(guo)征服朝(chao)(chao)鮮來(lai)確(que)保物資供應。
而朝(chao)鮮內部也分化為(wei)金尚(shang)憲、洪翼(yi)漢為(wei)代表(biao)的(de)(de)斥和(he)(he)(he)派和(he)(he)(he)金瑬、崔(cui)鳴(ming)吉(ji)為(wei)代表(biao)的(de)(de)主和(he)(he)(he)派,前者占絕(jue)大多數,以(yi)(yi)臺(tai)諫官員為(wei)主,后者則(ze)(ze)以(yi)(yi)仁(ren)祖(zu)反(fan)(fan)正功臣為(wei)主,兩派爭論(lun)不(bu)休。仁(ren)祖(zu)起初偏(pian)向(xiang)斥和(he)(he)(he)派,后來在崔(cui)鳴(ming)吉(ji)的(de)(de)反(fan)(fan)復(fu)勸諫下傾向(xiang)“守和(he)(he)(he)”,按照崔(cui)鳴(ming)吉(ji)的(de)(de)建(jian)議派遣譯官去清朝(chao),溝(gou)通(tong)緩和(he)(he)(he)雙邊關系,力圖·維持“兄弟(di)之(zhi)(zhi)國”的(de)(de)狀態。十(shi)月(yue)入清的(de)(de)譯使樸(pu)仁(ren)范(fan)等所攜國書被皇(huang)太極拒(ju)絕(jue)接受,皇(huang)太極隨后對朝(chao)鮮下最后通(tong)牒,要求十(shi)一月(yue)二十(shi)五(wu)日前送來王(wang)子、大臣來“更定和(he)(he)(he)議”,否則(ze)(ze)將(jiang)“大舉(ju)東(dong)搶”。仁(ren)祖(zu)對此痛苦地說:“欲(yu)為(wei)守御之(zhi)(zhi)備,則(ze)(ze)形勢如此;欲(yu)為(wei)羈縻之(zhi)(zhi)策,則(ze)(ze)名士輩皆曰不(bu)可。賊來而已,將(jiang)如之(zhi)(zhi)何?”表(biao)達了(le)(le)他(ta)既(ji)無力防備清軍入侵、又(you)面臨斥和(he)(he)(he)派(所謂(wei)“名士輩”)輿論(lun)壓力的(de)(de)進(jin)退兩難(nan)之(zhi)(zhi)境。最終(zhong),仁(ren)祖(zu)頂住朝(chao)中斥和(he)(he)(he)派的(de)(de)壓力,又(you)派譯官樸(pu)蘭(lan)英出使清朝(chao),在樸(pu)蘭(lan)英北上途中,丙子之(zhi)(zhi)役就爆發了(le)(le)。
崇禎九(jiu)(jiu)年(1636年,崇德元年)十(shi)(shi)(shi)一月十(shi)(shi)(shi)九(jiu)(jiu)日(ri),皇太(tai)極(ji)命(ming)兵(bing)部貝勒岳托(tuo)召(zhao)集(ji)眾臣于(yu)篤恭殿,宣布將親征朝鮮(xian)(xian),以懲其“敗(bai)盟逆命(ming)”之罪(zui),要求每牛(niu)錄各選騎(qi)兵(bing)15人(ren)、步兵(bing)10人(ren)、護軍(jun)(jun)7人(ren)、共甲32副(fu),昂邦(bang)章京(jing)石廷柱(zhu)所統漢(han)軍(jun)(jun)每甲士1人(ren)箭50枝,甲12人(ren)備長(chang)槍1桿,2牛(niu)錄備云梯(ti)、挨牌各1副(fu),并備齊(qi)各種器械(xie)及(ji)馬(ma)匹,攜半月行糧,于(yu)二(er)十(shi)(shi)(shi)九(jiu)(jiu)日(ri)集(ji)合。十(shi)(shi)(shi)一月二(er)十(shi)(shi)(shi)五日(ri)(冬至(zhi)),皇太(tai)極(ji)祭(ji)告天地、太(tai)廟,“告征朝鮮(xian)(xian)之由”,列舉了(le)朝鮮(xian)(xian)在薩爾滸(hu)之戰(zhan)時(shi)“助明(ming)來侵”、在遼沈之戰(zhan)后“招(zhao)誘遼民”、在丁卯之役后“屢敗(bai)盟誓(shi)”等罪(zui)狀。十(shi)(shi)(shi)二(er)月一日(ri),外藩蒙古的兵(bing)馬(ma)趕到盛(sheng)京(jing)會合,參與討伐朝鮮(xian)(xian)。皇太(tai)極(ji)安排(pai)鄭親王(wang)濟爾哈朗留守盛(sheng)京(jing),武英郡王(wang)阿濟格駐牛(niu)莊(zhuang)、饒(rao)余貝勒阿巴泰駐海(hai)城,以防備明(ming)軍(jun)(jun)。翌日(ri),皇太(tai)極(ji)祭(ji)堂子誓(shi)師,正式出發(fa)。
十(shi)二月(yue)三日(ri),馬福塔、勞薩(sa)等率領(ling)300名偽裝成商人(ren)的(de)(de)清軍率先從沙(sha)河(he)堡(bao)(今遼寧鞍山沙(sha)河(he)街道)出發。十(shi)二月(yue)八日(ri)(1637年1月(yue)3日(ri)),這(zhe)支清軍渡過結(jie)冰的(de)(de)鴨綠(lv)江(jiang),揭開了丙子之役的(de)(de)序幕(mu)。朝鮮(xian)軍龜(gui)縮山城,不(bu)敢(gan)阻截,致(zhi)使清軍前(qian)鋒部隊一路(lu)高歌猛進,如入無(wu)人(ren)之境。十(shi)二月(yue)十(shi)二日(ri),朝鮮(xian)朝廷接到(dao)義州(zhou)府尹(yin)林慶業驚(jing)呼鴨綠(lv)江(jiang)邊“賊兵彌漫”的(de)(de)馳啟(qi)(急報),但未引起(qi)足夠重視(shi),判斷只是清軍在邊境耀武揚(yang)威的(de)(de)“脅和(he)之計”而已。十(shi)二月(yue)十(shi)三日(ri),都元帥金(jin)自點馳啟(qi):“賊兵已到(dao)安州(zhou)。”朝鮮(xian)仁(ren)祖(zu)(zu)(zu)這(zhe)才(cai)緊急召(zhao)見大(da)臣,商討對策。領(ling)議政金(jin)瑬主張火(huo)速征兵,并請仁(ren)祖(zu)(zu)(zu)臨幸江(jiang)華島,但仁(ren)祖(zu)(zu)(zu)還是認為(wei)清軍不(bu)會深(shen)入,金(jin)瑬堅持請求,仁(ren)祖(zu)(zu)(zu)才(cai)勉強答應,但不(bu)同意世子分朝。同時奪(duo)情起(qi)復沈器遠為(wei)留(liu)都大(da)將(jiang),留(liu)守漢城。
十(shi)二(er)月十(shi)四(si)(si)日,朝鮮朝廷接(jie)報清(qing)(qing)軍(jun)前鋒已過開城,仁(ren)(ren)(ren)祖終(zhong)于“定(ding)去(qu)邠(周(zhou)太王去(qu)邠遷(qian)岐以(yi)躲(duo)避(bi)戎狄的(de)典(dian)故,指(zhi)遷(qian)都)之(zhi)(zhi)議”,安排金(jin)瑬之(zhi)(zhi)子(zi)金(jin)慶征、李敏求(qiu)(qiu)等(deng)護(hu)送(song)世子(zi)嬪姜氏(shi)(愍懷(huai)嬪)和鳳(feng)林(lin)(后(hou)來的(de)朝鮮孝宗)、麟坪(ping)兩大(da)君以(yi)及廟社神主(zhu)先行出發(fa)。史稱(cheng)其時“上下皇皇,罔知所為,都城士大(da)夫扶老攜(xie)幼,哭聲載路”。未時,仁(ren)(ren)(ren)祖及昭顯世子(zi)等(deng)出發(fa)前往(wang)(wang)江華島,剛到崇(chong)禮(li)門(南(nan)大(da)門),就聽(ting)說(shuo)(shuo)清(qing)(qing)軍(jun)前鋒部隊已抵達漢(han)城西郊的(de)弘濟(ji)院,朝鮮訓練都監(jian)將官李興業率領的(de)80多(duo)(duo)人(ren)(ren)(一說(shuo)(shuo)60多(duo)(duo)人(ren)(ren))的(de)小股騎兵被清(qing)(qing)軍(jun)擊敗。吏曹判書崔(cui)鳴(ming)吉(ji)請求(qiu)(qiu)去(qu)清(qing)(qing)營周(zhou)旋以(yi)緩師(shi),仁(ren)(ren)(ren)祖同(tong)意,崔(cui)鳴(ming)吉(ji)和都承旨李景稷便設宴歡迎馬福(fu)塔、勞薩(sa)等(deng),仁(ren)(ren)(ren)祖一行趁機轉進漢(han)城南(nan)四(si)(si)十(shi)里(li)的(de)南(nan)漢(han)山(shan)城。翌日清(qing)(qing)晨,仁(ren)(ren)(ren)祖在(zai)金(jin)瑬等(deng)人(ren)(ren)的(de)勸說(shuo)(shuo)下打算從(cong)南(nan)漢(han)山(shan)城前往(wang)(wang)江華島,然而(er)風雪甚緊,一路顛仆,被迫折返南(nan)漢(han)山(shan)城,其后(hou)仁(ren)(ren)(ren)祖擔(dan)心中途(tu)被清(qing)(qing)軍(jun)俘虜,聽(ting)從(cong)南(nan)漢(han)山(shan)城守(shou)御使李時白的(de)建議,不再考慮逃往(wang)(wang)江華島,決定(ding)死(si)守(shou)南(nan)漢(han)山(shan)城。
南漢山(shan)城防(fang)守部署是:
訓練(lian)大將申(shen)景禛,負責(ze)東城望月臺(tai);
總戎使(shi)具(ju)宏,負(fu)責南(nan)城;
守(shou)御使李(li)時白,負責西城;
軍器寺提調李曙(后因病,改(gai)以御營大將元斗(dou)杓),負責北城。
十(shi)(shi)二(er)月十(shi)(shi)五日,崔鳴吉從(cong)清(qing)營(ying)回(hui)來,轉告了馬(ma)福塔(ta)等提出(chu)的(de)王(wang)(wang)弟與大(da)臣(chen)(指(zhi)政(zheng)丞(cheng)級別的(de)大(da)臣(chen))為人(ren)質的(de)議(yi)(yi)和(he)條件(jian),于是(shi)仁(ren)祖派(pai)遠房(fang)王(wang)(wang)族李(li)偁冒充王(wang)(wang)弟、刑(xing)曹判書沈(shen)諿作為大(da)臣(chen)前(qian)往清(qing)營(ying)。清(qing)軍逼問兩人(ren)是(shi)否是(shi)真(zhen)(zhen)王(wang)(wang)弟、真(zhen)(zhen)大(da)臣(chen)時,沈(shen)諿不(bu)敢回(hui)答,遂被清(qing)軍識破,在清(qing)營(ying)中的(de)朝鮮(xian)使臣(chen)樸(pu)蘭英堅(jian)稱二(er)人(ren)為真(zhen)(zhen),為清(qing)軍所殺,清(qing)軍揚言必須(xu)送出(chu)世(shi)子(zi)才能(neng)議(yi)(yi)和(he)。十(shi)(shi)二(er)月十(shi)(shi)七(qi)日,仁(ren)祖派(pai)左(zuo)議(yi)(yi)政(zheng)洪瑞(rui)鳳、戶曹判書金(jin)藎國、都(dou)承旨李(li)景稷前(qian)往清(qing)營(ying),清(qing)方還是(shi)堅(jian)持必須(xu)世(shi)子(zi)出(chu)來當人(ren)質,仁(ren)祖本有意答應(ying),但遭到(dao)禮曹判書金(jin)尚憲、駙馬(ma)東陽尉(wei)申翊(yi)圣(sheng)和(he)臺諫(jian)兩司(司憲府、司諫(jian)院(yuan))為首的(de)斥和(he)派(pai)官員的(de)堅(jian)決反對而(er)未(wei)果,雙方首次(ci)交涉(she)就此破裂(lie)。
十(shi)二月十(shi)六(liu)日,皇太(tai)極(ji)緊接著派(pai)遣的多鐸(duo)、岳托等人(ren)所(suo)率部隊與馬(ma)福塔(ta)會(hui)師,初步包圍南漢山(shan)城,“立(li)(li)柵困之(zhi)(zhi)”。仁(ren)(ren)祖面(mian)對這種局(ju)面(mian)痛(tong)心疾首,曾哭著對群臣說:“三百年(nian)血誠事(shi)大(da),受恩深重(zhong),而一(yi)朝(chao)逢(feng)廢(fei)朝(chao)(光海(hai)君(jun))時(shi)所(suo)未(wei)有(you)之(zhi)(zhi)事(shi),諸(zhu)(zhu)卿諸(zhu)(zhu)卿,此(ci)何(he)為哉(zai)?當(dang)倫紀斁滅之(zhi)(zhi)時(shi),幸與當(dang)時(shi)立(li)(li)節之(zhi)(zhi)諸(zhu)(zhu)賢為此(ci)撥亂之(zhi)(zhi)事(shi)業,居人(ren)君(jun)之(zhi)(zhi)位、行(xing)人(ren)君(jun)之(zhi)(zhi)事(shi)者(zhe),今十(shi)四(si)年(nian)矣(yi)。豈料終歸犬羊禽獸也哉(zai)?然(ran)諸(zhu)(zhu)卿有(you)何(he)所(suo)失?緣予薄劣無狀,致有(you)此(ci)罔極(ji)之(zhi)(zhi)變也。諸(zhu)(zhu)卿諸(zhu)(zhu)卿,奈何(he)奈何(he)!”十(shi)二月十(shi)八日,仁(ren)(ren)祖出(chu)行(xing)宮南門,頒布教書,宣布“君(jun)臣上(shang)下,同守一(yi)城,和(he)議已絕,唯有(you)戰(zhan)(zhan)耳”,正式確(que)立(li)(li)了“戰(zhan)(zhan)守”的方針(zhen)。其后(hou)他(ta)拒絕了清軍(jun)使者(zhe)的和(he)談要求,并主(zhu)張趁清軍(jun)尚未(wei)完成包圍之(zhi)(zhi)際“宜一(yi)番決戰(zhan)(zhan)”。從十(shi)二月十(shi)八日至二十(shi)九(jiu)日,朝(chao)鮮軍(jun)屢次出(chu)城作戰(zhan)(zhan),主(zhu)要有(you):
十二(er)月十八日,北門大將元(yuan)斗杓率(lv)軍出(chu)戰,殺清兵6人;
十二月十九日(ri),總戎使具宏募炮手出城邀擊清(qing)軍,殺清(qing)兵20人(一說5、6人),奪取馬匹;
十二月二十一日(ri),御營別將李起榮率兵(bing)出西(xi)門,殺(sha)清兵(bing)10余人,東門大(da)將申景禛亦(yi)出戰(zhan);
十(shi)二(er)月二(er)十(shi)二(er)日,北(bei)門御(yu)營軍殺清兵10余(yu)人(ren),東門大將申景禛殺清兵30余(yu)人(ren),幾次出戰,朝鮮軍只陣亡(wang)5、6人(ren);
十二月(yue)二十三日,自(zi)募(mu)軍出戰,殺清兵約50人;
十二月二十四日(ri),發兵(bing)400人(ren)出戰,斬獲(huo)頗(po)多;
十二月二十九日,發(fa)兵(bing)600人(ren)(ren)出戰,至山城(cheng)下平地,清(qing)(qing)軍不接戰,日暮(mu),體(ti)察使金瑬傳(chuan)令收兵(bing),清(qing)(qing)軍趁(chen)機奇襲,別(bie)將申誠立以(yi)下數百人(ren)(ren)陣亡。
在十(shi)二(er)月二(er)十(shi)九(jiu)日的慘(can)敗后,“城中大震,上(shang)下色沮”,加(jia)上(shang)清軍主力已經趕到,朝鮮遂(sui)喪失(shi)斗志(zhi),龜(gui)縮城中,不敢主動出(chu)戰。當時南漢山城有兵13000多人,所儲糧食還可以(yi)支(zhi)撐到二(er)月下旬。
此(ci)(ci)前(qian),皇(huang)太(tai)(tai)極已于十(shi)(shi)(shi)(shi)二(er)(er)月(yue)(yue)十(shi)(shi)(shi)(shi)日(ri)(ri)(ri)率右翼(yi)軍(jun)(jun)(jun)(jun)進入朝(chao)(chao)鮮境內(nei),郭山、定州(zhou)等(deng)地朝(chao)(chao)鮮軍(jun)(jun)(jun)(jun)民迎(ying)降,皇(huang)太(tai)(tai)極命(ming)順民剃發。十(shi)(shi)(shi)(shi)三(san)日(ri)(ri)(ri),命(ming)杜(du)度擄走皮島鄰近地區的(de)所有(you)朝(chao)(chao)鮮人(ren)。十(shi)(shi)(shi)(shi)五日(ri)(ri)(ri)抵(di)(di)達安(an)州(zhou),平(ping)安(an)兵使柳(liu)琳在(zai)此(ci)(ci)堅守,皇(huang)太(tai)(tai)極并未強攻(gong)(gong),而是曉(xiao)諭柳(liu)琳之(zhi)后繼續(xu)南(nan)下。途中(zhong)在(zai)十(shi)(shi)(shi)(shi)二(er)(er)月(yue)(yue)十(shi)(shi)(shi)(shi)九日(ri)(ri)(ri)、二(er)(er)十(shi)(shi)(shi)(shi)一(yi)日(ri)(ri)(ri)、二(er)(er)十(shi)(shi)(shi)(shi)五日(ri)(ri)(ri)接到多(duo)鐸關于朝(chao)(chao)鮮王退守南(nan)漢(han)山城(cheng)(cheng)的(de)報(bao)告,乃于十(shi)(shi)(shi)(shi)二(er)(er)月(yue)(yue)二(er)(er)十(shi)(shi)(shi)(shi)五日(ri)(ri)(ri)急派增(zeng)援兵力,二(er)(er)十(shi)(shi)(shi)(shi)六日(ri)(ri)(ri)派筆帖式(shi)吳達禮(li)等(deng)前(qian)去(qu)敦促后衛杜(du)度“速攜(xie)紅(hong)衣、大將軍(jun)(jun)(jun)(jun)炮(pao)(pao)及一(yi)切火器前(qian)來”。皇(huang)太(tai)(tai)極于十(shi)(shi)(shi)(shi)二(er)(er)月(yue)(yue)二(er)(er)十(shi)(shi)(shi)(shi)九日(ri)(ri)(ri)渡過漢(han)江,在(zai)南(nan)漢(han)山城(cheng)(cheng)西側(ce)設置御營,同時命(ming)固山額真譚泰等(deng)攻(gong)(gong)取漢(han)城(cheng)(cheng),搜(sou)捕朝(chao)(chao)鮮軍(jun)(jun)(jun)(jun)人(ren),掠奪財物牲畜。翌年正月(yue)(yue)四日(ri)(ri)(ri),移御營于漢(han)江北(bei)岸,同日(ri)(ri)(ri),三(san)順王(孔有(you)德、耿(geng)仲明、尚(shang)可喜)和烏(wu)真超哈(ha)的(de)金玉和攜(xie)火炮(pao)(pao)抵(di)(di)達南(nan)漢(han)山城(cheng)(cheng)。正月(yue)(yue)十(shi)(shi)(shi)(shi)日(ri)(ri)(ri),率左翼(yi)軍(jun)(jun)(jun)(jun)南(nan)下的(de)多(duo)爾袞和豪格等(deng)抵(di)(di)達御營,向(xiang)皇(huang)太(tai)(tai)極匯報(bao)這段時間的(de)戰(zhan)果。同日(ri)(ri)(ri),杜(du)度等(deng)帶著(zhu)包(bao)括紅(hong)夷炮(pao)(pao)在(zai)內(nei)的(de)火藥武器與重裝(zhuang)備抵(di)(di)達清軍(jun)(jun)(jun)(jun)陣營,切斷南(nan)漢(han)山城(cheng)(cheng)的(de)內(nei)外聯絡,徹底(di)完成(cheng)了(le)對南(nan)漢(han)山城(cheng)(cheng)包(bao)圍。
仁祖君(jun)臣(chen)被困在南漢山城期間,亦寄希望(wang)于朝鮮(xian)八道勤王(wang)兵(bing)(bing)(bing)(bing)來援(yuan)救(jiu),遂于十(shi)(shi)二月(yue)十(shi)(shi)七日頒布教書,稱自己是為了固(gu)守與明(ming)朝的君(jun)臣(chen)大(da)義(yi)(yi)才遭清(qing)(qing)軍(jun)(jun)入侵(qin),號召(zhao)諸道士民也要對國王(wang)盡君(jun)臣(chen)之(zhi)義(yi)(yi)、起兵(bing)(bing)(bing)(bing)勤王(wang)。十(shi)(shi)二月(yue)二十(shi)(shi)一(yi)日,有定居朝鮮(xian)的女真瓦爾喀人投奔清(qing)(qing)軍(jun)(jun),報告了此情報,于是多鐸派阿爾津(jin)、色(se)勒前去堵截朝鮮(xian)勤王(wang)兵(bing)(bing)(bing)(bing)。從十(shi)(shi)二月(yue)到翌年正月(yue),各路朝鮮(xian)勤王(wang)兵(bing)(bing)(bing)(bing)被清(qing)(qing)軍(jun)(jun)先后擊(ji)退(tui),“赴難(nan)之(zhi)兵(bing)(bing)(bing)(bing),一(yi)無(wu)成功者”。金(jin)自點、沈器遠等退(tui)守京畿道楊(yang)根郡之(zhi)迷原(yuan)(又作(zuo)薇原(yuan)、薇園)縣,按兵(bing)(bing)(bing)(bing)不(bu)動,試圖聚合大(da)軍(jun)(jun)后反攻。朝鮮(xian)平安道觀察使(shi)洪(hong)命耇、慶尚(shang)左兵(bing)(bing)(bing)(bing)使(shi)許完、右兵(bing)(bing)(bing)(bing)使(shi)閔栐、忠清(qing)(qing)兵(bing)(bing)(bing)(bing)使(shi)李(li)義(yi)(yi)培等文武(wu)大(da)員陣亡,但清(qing)(qing)軍(jun)(jun)高級將領揚古利亦遭朝鮮(xian)伏兵(bing)(bing)(bing)(bing)用鳥槍擊(ji)斃。
十(shi)二(er)月(yue)(yue)二(er)十(shi)九(jiu)日(ri)以后,朝(chao)鮮(xian)(xian)君(jun)臣龜縮于南漢(han)(han)山城(cheng)中(zhong),不(bu)敢(gan)出戰(zhan),皇(huang)(huang)太極(ji)亦率清(qing)軍主(zhu)力趕到(dao),加緊構筑(zhu)對南漢(han)(han)山城(cheng)的(de)(de)(de)(de)包圍網,重啟(qi)議(yi)和再次成為朝(chao)鮮(xian)(xian)仁(ren)祖的(de)(de)(de)(de)選擇。正月(yue)(yue)初一,清(qing)方拒絕了朝(chao)鮮(xian)(xian)方面送來的(de)(de)(de)(de)賀年禮物(wu),但向使臣傳(chuan)話說(shuo)明天(tian)(tian)再來,留下(xia)了協(xie)商的(de)(de)(de)(de)余地。正月(yue)(yue)二(er)日(ri),洪瑞(rui)鳳(feng)、金(jin)藎國、李景稷(ji)被派往清(qing)營,返(fan)回(hui)后轉達(da)了皇(huang)(huang)太極(ji)的(de)(de)(de)(de)“詔諭”,在該“詔諭”中(zhong),皇(huang)(huang)太極(ji)強(qiang)調戰(zhan)爭爆發的(de)(de)(de)(de)責任(ren)在朝(chao)鮮(xian)(xian)一方。正月(yue)(yue)三日(ri),洪、金(jin)、李三人赴(fu)清(qing)營送去崔鳴(ming)吉撰寫的(de)(de)(de)(de)國書,對前一日(ri)皇(huang)(huang)太極(ji)的(de)(de)(de)(de)責難進(jin)行(xing)辯解,并懇請(qing)皇(huang)(huang)太極(ji)原諒(liang)朝(chao)鮮(xian)(xian),撤退清(qing)軍,恢復丁卯之(zhi)役后的(de)(de)(de)(de)“兄弟(di)之(zhi)國”狀態。但皇(huang)(huang)太極(ji)對仁(ren)祖的(de)(de)(de)(de)國書不(bu)予答復,雙方在此后十(shi)天(tian)(tian)的(de)(de)(de)(de)時間里(li)沒有(you)任(ren)何(he)接觸。
此(ci)時清(qing)軍(jun)已將南(nan)漢(han)山城圍得水泄不(bu)通,諸道(dao)勤王兵又被各個擊(ji)破(po),朝(chao)(chao)鮮朝(chao)(chao)廷被迫于(yu)正(zheng)月(yue)十(shi)(shi)一(yi)日(ri)寫(xie)出(chu)國書,繼續之(zhi)前的(de)(de)訴(su)求,次日(ri)派洪瑞鳳(feng)、崔鳴吉、尹(yin)暉等送到清(qing)軍(jun)陣(zhen)營。清(qing)方先(xian)以(yi)日(ri)暮為由不(bu)受,第(di)二(er)天(tian)洪瑞鳳(feng)等又來,清(qing)方才接受這封(feng)國書。但(dan)皇(huang)太(tai)極對(dui)(dui)這封(feng)國書還(huan)是不(bu)予(yu)答(da)復。仁祖非常焦(jiao)急,便于(yu)正(zheng)月(yue)十(shi)(shi)六日(ri)又派洪瑞鳳(feng)、崔鳴吉、尹(yin)暉三人去清(qing)營,詢問(wen)皇(huang)太(tai)極的(de)(de)態度。負責對(dui)(dui)朝(chao)(chao)交涉(she)的(de)(de)英俄(e)爾岱說(shuo):“若無新(xin)語(yu),不(bu)須更來!”暗示朝(chao)(chao)鮮必須先(xian)向清(qing)朝(chao)(chao)稱臣方可和(he)談,此(ci)外(wai)還(huan)透露(lu)清(qing)軍(jun)將進攻江華島。同(tong)日(ri),清(qing)軍(jun)在望月(yue)峰下樹起一(yi)面(mian)寫(xie)有“招降”二(er)字(zi)的(de)(de)白旗,不(bu)過被大風(feng)吹斷。
正(zheng)月(yue)十(shi)(shi)七日(ri)(ri)(ri),皇(huang)太(tai)極(ji)(ji)終于答復(fu)朝(chao)鮮,對朝(chao)鮮的(de)(de)辯解逐條駁斥(chi),要(yao)(yao)求仁(ren)(ren)(ren)祖做出(chu)抉擇:“欲生耶,亟宜(yi)出(chu)城(cheng)(cheng)歸命;欲戰(zhan)(zhan)耶,亦(yi)宜(yi)亟出(chu)一戰(zhan)(zhan)!”正(zheng)月(yue)十(shi)(shi)八(ba)日(ri)(ri)(ri),皇(huang)太(tai)極(ji)(ji)又(you)派人到(dao)南漢山城(cheng)(cheng)下(xia)喊話(hua),敦促朝(chao)鮮國(guo)(guo)王盡快出(chu)城(cheng)(cheng),否則將于十(shi)(shi)九日(ri)(ri)(ri)或(huo)二(er)十(shi)(shi)一日(ri)(ri)(ri)決戰(zhan)(zhan)。仁(ren)(ren)(ren)祖看出(chu)了皇(huang)太(tai)極(ji)(ji)的(de)(de)這道“詔諭(yu)”雖(sui)然措辭(ci)嚴厲(li),但“亦(yi)有容許之(zhi)意”,故決定繼續交涉。然而,朝(chao)鮮主和(he)派與(yu)斥(chi)和(he)派的(de)(de)對立(li)已經白熱(re)化,崔鳴(ming)(ming)吉(ji)(ji)寫出(chu)國(guo)(guo)書(shu)(shu),言辭(ci)卑屈,大意是(shi)婉(wan)(wan)拒出(chu)城(cheng)(cheng),希(xi)望能(neng)“城(cheng)(cheng)上拜天(tian)子(zi)”(指高句(ju)麗安市城(cheng)(cheng)主在(zai)城(cheng)(cheng)上拜送(song)唐太(tai)宗(zong)之(zhi)故事,崔鳴(ming)(ming)吉(ji)(ji)認為清朝(chao)不(bu)知此事)。金尚(shang)憲(xian)看到(dao)國(guo)(guo)書(shu)(shu)稱(cheng)皇(huang)太(tai)極(ji)(ji)為“陛(bi)下(xia)”(意味著(zhu)兩(liang)國(guo)(guo)變為君(jun)臣(chen)(chen)關系),痛哭流涕,撕掉國(guo)(guo)書(shu)(shu),崔鳴(ming)(ming)吉(ji)(ji)重寫時(shi)不(bu)得不(bu)刪(shan)除“陛(bi)下(xia)”兩(liang)字,當天(tian)和(he)洪(hong)瑞(rui)鳳、尹暉一起送(song)到(dao)清營,英(ying)俄爾(er)岱(dai)、馬(ma)福塔(ta)(ta)不(bu)受(shou)。第二(er)天(tian),朝(chao)鮮方(fang)面在(zai)國(guo)(guo)書(shu)(shu)中加了“陛(bi)下(xia)”兩(liang)字,由右議政李弘胄(洪(hong)瑞(rui)鳳稱(cheng)病(bing))、崔鳴(ming)(ming)吉(ji)(ji)、尹暉再次(ci)送(song)去(qu),但英(ying)俄爾(er)岱(dai)、馬(ma)福塔(ta)(ta)堅持要(yao)(yao)求朝(chao)鮮國(guo)(guo)王出(chu)城(cheng)(cheng),雙(shuang)方(fang)爭執不(bu)下(xia)。正(zheng)月(yue)二(er)十(shi)(shi)日(ri)(ri)(ri),皇(huang)太(tai)極(ji)(ji)又(you)下(xia)達“詔諭(yu)”,在(zai)“出(chu)城(cheng)(cheng)歸命”之(zhi)外(wai)拋出(chu)了“縛送(song)斥(chi)和(he)臣(chen)(chen)”的(de)(de)條件,仁(ren)(ren)(ren)祖表示無法(fa)接受(shou)。翌(yi)日(ri)(ri)(ri),仁(ren)(ren)(ren)祖派李弘胄等(deng)送(song)去(qu)答復(fu)國(guo)(guo)書(shu)(shu),雖(sui)然這封國(guo)(guo)書(shu)(shu)明確向(xiang)皇(huang)太(tai)極(ji)(ji)稱(cheng)臣(chen)(chen),但還是(shi)婉(wan)(wan)拒了國(guo)(guo)王出(chu)城(cheng)(cheng)和(he)縛送(song)斥(chi)和(he)臣(chen)(chen)這兩(liang)個條件,英(ying)俄爾(er)岱(dai)、馬(ma)福塔(ta)(ta)等(deng)拒受(shou)國(guo)(guo)書(shu)(shu),雙(shuang)方(fang)不(bu)歡而散(san)。
正月二十二日(ri),清(qing)(qing)軍(jun)(jun)(jun)用車載著(zhu)82艘(sou)(一說(shuo)44艘(sou))舢板(ban)小(xiao)船(chuan)(chuan),在(zai)多(duo)爾袞的(de)率(lv)(lv)領下(xia)進攻(gong)江(jiang)(jiang)(jiang)華(hua)(hua)島(dao)(dao)。當(dang)時(shi),朝(chao)(chao)鮮(xian)的(de)廟社神主、世子(zi)嬪、兩(liang)大(da)君、元孫(sun)等王(wang)室人員及大(da)臣(chen)(chen)家(jia)眷都(dou)(dou)藏身于(yu)江(jiang)(jiang)(jiang)華(hua)(hua)島(dao)(dao),負責防(fang)務的(de)是(shi)江(jiang)(jiang)(jiang)華(hua)(hua)留(liu)守(shou)(shou)(shou)兼舟師大(da)將張(zhang)紳(shen)(shen)(shen)(shen),守(shou)(shou)(shou)島(dao)(dao)兵力(li)約1000人。此(ci)外,島(dao)(dao)上(shang)(shang)還(huan)有檢察使金慶征、副使李敏求,不(bu)過兩(liang)人并無(wu)兵權。江(jiang)(jiang)(jiang)華(hua)(hua)海峽(鹽河)被視為(wei)天(tian)塹,當(dang)時(shi)還(huan)浮(fu)著(zhu)冰,所(suo)(suo)以(yi)盡管清(qing)(qing)軍(jun)(jun)(jun)早就放出攻(gong)取江(jiang)(jiang)(jiang)華(hua)(hua)島(dao)(dao)的(de)風聲,朝(chao)(chao)鮮(xian)朝(chao)(chao)廷也征發(fa)諸(zhu)道水(shui)(shui)師防(fang)備(bei)江(jiang)(jiang)(jiang)華(hua)(hua)海峽,但朝(chao)(chao)鮮(xian)人都(dou)(dou)認為(wei)這是(shi)清(qing)(qing)軍(jun)(jun)(jun)虛張(zhang)聲勢。江(jiang)(jiang)(jiang)華(hua)(hua)留(liu)守(shou)(shou)(shou)張(zhang)紳(shen)(shen)(shen)(shen)也“謂虜不(bu)能飛渡”,有人勸他(ta)加強(qiang)防(fang)備(bei),他(ta)就斥其膽(dan)怯。二十二日(ri)上(shang)(shang)午(wu),多(duo)爾袞發(fa)動(dong)渡海作戰,直指江(jiang)(jiang)(jiang)華(hua)(hua)島(dao)(dao)北(bei)(bei)面(mian)朝(chao)(chao)鮮(xian)守(shou)(shou)(shou)軍(jun)(jun)(jun)防(fang)備(bei)虛弱的(de)甲(jia)串(chuan)津。張(zhang)紳(shen)(shen)(shen)(shen)率(lv)(lv)軍(jun)(jun)(jun)乘27艘(sou)板(ban)屋船(chuan)(chuan)從(cong)廣城(cheng)鎮北(bei)(bei)上(shang)(shang),忠清(qing)(qing)水(shui)(shui)使姜(jiang)晉(jin)(jin)(jin)昕亦率(lv)(lv)7艘(sou)板(ban)屋船(chuan)(chuan)從(cong)燕尾亭南(nan)下(xia),企(qi)圖攔截(jie)清(qing)(qing)軍(jun)(jun)(jun)。不(bu)料由(you)于(yu)退(tui)潮的(de)緣故,張(zhang)紳(shen)(shen)(shen)(shen)所(suo)(suo)率(lv)(lv)水(shui)(shui)軍(jun)(jun)(jun)在(zai)離甲(jia)串(chuan)津數百步處的(de)海域停滯不(bu)前(qian),姜(jiang)晉(jin)(jin)(jin)昕所(suo)(suo)率(lv)(lv)水(shui)(shui)軍(jun)(jun)(jun)雖能南(nan)下(xia),卻因多(duo)爾袞連(lian)放紅夷大(da)炮而(er)迅速敗退(tui),姜(jiang)晉(jin)(jin)(jin)昕亦負傷。中午(wu)時(shi)分(fen),清(qing)(qing)軍(jun)(jun)(jun)成(cheng)功登陸甲(jia)串(chuan)。由(you)于(yu)江(jiang)(jiang)(jiang)華(hua)(hua)守(shou)(shou)(shou)軍(jun)(jun)(jun)都(dou)(dou)被張(zhang)紳(shen)(shen)(shen)(shen)調走,張(zhang)紳(shen)(shen)(shen)(shen)水(shui)(shui)軍(jun)(jun)(jun)又(you)因退(tui)潮而(er)動(dong)彈不(bu)得,所(suo)(suo)以(yi)江(jiang)(jiang)(jiang)華(hua)(hua)島(dao)(dao)輕易落入(ru)清(qing)(qing)軍(jun)(jun)(jun)手(shou)中,只有朝(chao)(chao)鮮(xian)中軍(jun)(jun)(jun)黃善身率(lv)(lv)113人抵抗清(qing)(qing)軍(jun)(jun)(jun),旋即戰死。鳳林大(da)君也帶著(zhu)勇(yong)士(shi)試(shi)圖抵抗而(er)未果,最終(zhong)交出江(jiang)(jiang)(jiang)華(hua)(hua)府城(cheng),向多(duo)爾袞投降。前(qian)右議政金尚容在(zai)江(jiang)(jiang)(jiang)華(hua)(hua)府城(cheng)南(nan)門引爆火藥自殺,其余包括世子(zi)嬪、兩(liang)大(da)君、元孫(sun)等在(zai)內的(de)240多(duo)名(ming)朝(chao)(chao)鮮(xian)王(wang)室人員、大(da)臣(chen)(chen)及其眷屬(shu)成(cheng)為(wei)清(qing)(qing)軍(jun)(jun)(jun)的(de)俘虜。二十五日(ri),多(duo)爾袞帶著(zhu)戰俘離開江(jiang)(jiang)(jiang)華(hua)(hua)島(dao)(dao)。
正月二十三(san)日(ri)(ri)夜,清(qing)軍(jun)襲擊南(nan)漢山城,被(bei)南(nan)漢山城守御使李(li)時(shi)白(bai)擊退(tui)。其后,清(qing)軍(jun)連日(ri)(ri)向南(nan)漢山城發射(she)紅夷炮(pao),對朝鮮施加壓(ya)力。時(shi)人記載:“炮(pao)丸(wan)大(da)(da)如(ru)(ru)鵝(e)卵,或(huo)有如(ru)(ru)小兒頭者,能(neng)飛越(yue)岡巒,亂觸宮墻,聲震天地,晝(zhou)夜不絕,城中之(zhi)人,比比中死,堞所觸皆崩潰,人心(xin)因此大(da)(da)洶(xiong)”。二十三(san)日(ri)(ri),朝鮮已決定交出(chu)斥和派大(da)(da)臣,翌(yi)日(ri)(ri),洪瑞鳳、崔(cui)鳴吉、尹暉送(song)國(guo)(guo)書(shu)(shu)于清(qing)營,然而國(guo)(guo)王出(chu)城一事仍不肯就(jiu)范(fan)。二十五日(ri)(ri),英(ying)俄爾岱、馬福塔退(tui)還朝鮮國(guo)(guo)書(shu)(shu),并向崔(cui)鳴吉等發出(chu)最后通牒(die),說皇太極即將回國(guo)(guo),如(ru)(ru)果國(guo)(guo)王再不出(chu)城,就(jiu)不會再有和談的(de)(de)余地了,同時(shi)告知諸道勤王兵已被(bei)清(qing)軍(jun)各個(ge)擊破的(de)(de)消息。
二(er)十(shi)(shi)六日(ri)上午,受不了(le)清(qing)(qing)(qing)(qing)軍紅夷炮的(de)(de)朝鮮守(shou)(shou)城(cheng)(cheng)將(jiang)士(shi)嘩變,來(lai)到行宮門(men)外兵諫,要(yao)求立即交出金(jin)尚(shang)憲等斥和(he)派(pai)(pai)大(da)(da)臣。仁(ren)(ren)祖(zu)(zu)(zu)企圖讓(rang)世(shi)子(zi)出城(cheng)(cheng)來(lai)緩解壓力(li)(此前(qian)世(shi)子(zi)曾多次請求代(dai)父(fu)出城(cheng)(cheng),未獲允許(xu)),便派(pai)(pai)洪瑞鳳、崔(cui)鳴(ming)(ming)吉(ji)、金(jin)藎(jin)國(guo)前(qian)往清(qing)(qing)(qing)(qing)營,告知世(shi)子(zi)將(jiang)出城(cheng)(cheng)。英俄(e)爾岱(dai)說:“今則非國(guo)王親出,決(jue)不可(ke)聽(ting)!”隨即將(jiang)大(da)(da)君手書和(he)兩個大(da)(da)臣的(de)(de)狀啟遞(di)給洪瑞鳳等,江華島失守(shou)(shou)的(de)(de)噩耗這才傳入南(nan)(nan)漢山(shan)城(cheng)(cheng),“城(cheng)(cheng)中莫不痛(tong)哭”。江華島失守(shou)(shou)成(cheng)為壓垮仁(ren)(ren)祖(zu)(zu)(zu)的(de)(de)最(zui)后稻草(cao),當晚就決(jue)定(ding)出城(cheng)(cheng)投降。二(er)十(shi)(shi)七(qi)日(ri),仁(ren)(ren)祖(zu)(zu)(zu)派(pai)(pai)李弘(hong)(hong)胄、金(jin)藎(jin)國(guo)、崔(cui)鳴(ming)(ming)吉(ji)送去了(le)愿意出城(cheng)(cheng)向皇太極(ji)投降的(de)(de)國(guo)書,并(bing)希望清(qing)(qing)(qing)(qing)方能保證人身安全。二(er)十(shi)(shi)八日(ri),仁(ren)(ren)祖(zu)(zu)(zu)及金(jin)瑬、崔(cui)鳴(ming)(ming)吉(ji)等從金(jin)尚(shang)憲、鄭蘊、尹(yin)煌等十(shi)(shi)多名(ming)自首的(de)(de)斥和(he)派(pai)(pai)大(da)(da)臣中挑出了(le)弘(hong)(hong)文館校理尹(yin)集、修撰(zhuan)吳達濟二(er)人,準(zhun)備交給清(qing)(qing)(qing)(qing)朝(翌(yi)日(ri)由崔(cui)鳴(ming)(ming)吉(ji)、李英達帶(dai)去清(qing)(qing)(qing)(qing)營)。當晚,英俄(e)爾岱(dai)、馬福塔來(lai)到南(nan)(nan)漢山(shan)城(cheng)(cheng)南(nan)(nan)門(men),按(an)明(ming)使給朝鮮陪臣敕書的(de)(de)方式(shi)將(jiang)戰(zhan)時皇太極(ji)對朝鮮的(de)(de)最(zui)后一(yi)道(dao)“詔諭(yu)”遞(di)給洪瑞鳳、崔(cui)鳴(ming)(ming)吉(ji)、金(jin)藎(jin)國(guo)。皇太極(ji)在“詔諭(yu)”中宣布赦免(mian)仁(ren)(ren)祖(zu)(zu)(zu)之罪,并(bing)提出了(le)如(ru)下幾條(tiao)議和(he)條(tiao)件:
1.繳納明(ming)朝誥命、冊印,斷絕對明(ming)朝的宗藩關系,停(ting)用明(ming)朝年號,遵奉大清正朔;
2.納世子(zi)及另一王(wang)子(zi)為(wei)人質(zhi),諸大臣亦須出子(zi)弟(di)為(wei)質(zhi);
3.朝鮮(xian)有協助清軍攻(gong)明的(de)義務,當務之急就是配合清軍攻(gong)取皮島;
4.每逢清(qing)朝圣節、正朝、冬至及皇后(hou)、皇太子千秋節,朝鮮(xian)須按朝賀(he)明朝的舊例來奉表(biao)朝賀(he);
5.朝(chao)鮮俘(fu)虜渡過鴨綠江(jiang)后,如果逃回,朝(chao)鮮必須送(song)還,不(bu)得收留,但(dan)可按俘(fu)虜本主意愿贖回;
6.朝(chao)鮮(xian)須與清朝(chao)貴族聯姻;
7.朝(chao)鮮不得再修繕新(xin)舊城池(chi);
8.朝(chao)(chao)鮮(xian)須送還朝(chao)(chao)鮮(xian)境內所有瓦爾喀人(朝(chao)(chao)鮮(xian)稱兀(wu)良哈);
9.允許朝(chao)(chao)鮮繼續與日(ri)本貿易,朝(chao)(chao)鮮須(xu)協(xie)助清(qing)朝(chao)(chao)聯絡日(ri)本;
10.朝鮮不能再與(yu)圖們江外的瓦爾(er)喀人貿易,如(ru)果遇(yu)到瓦爾(er)喀人,必須扭送清朝;
11.規定歲貢數額。隨后兩國使(shi)臣(chen)交涉了朝(chao)鮮國王出城投降的(de)細節(jie)問題及繳納(na)明朝(chao)敕(chi)印和(he)攻擊皮(pi)島等事(shi)宜。仁祖對這些苛刻的(de)條(tiao)件(jian)(jian)非常不滿,說(shuo):“有(you)如此難從之(zhi)(zhi)(zhi)言,而(er)其可甘心(xin)受(shou)之(zhi)(zhi)(zhi)耶?”洪(hong)瑞鳳勸道(dao):“稱臣(chen)奉朔之(zhi)(zhi)(zhi)后,則更(geng)無可為之(zhi)(zhi)(zhi)事(shi)。今(jin)日之(zhi)(zhi)(zhi)勢(shi),少無以(yi)兵力擊卻之(zhi)(zhi)(zhi)路,亦將奈何(he)哉?”“今(jin)日之(zhi)(zhi)(zhi)權,都在于彼,勢(shi)難爭阻矣!”朝(chao)鮮遂(sui)只能(neng)無條(tiao)件(jian)(jian)接受(shou)。
崇禎十(shi)年(1637年,崇德(de)二年)正月(yue)(yue)三十(shi)日(ri)(2月(yue)(yue)24日(ri)),在(zai)漢江南岸的三田(tian)渡(du)所(suo)(suo)筑受(shou)(shou)降壇上(shang)(shang)(shang),皇太極接受(shou)(shou)了身(shen)穿(chuan)(chuan)藍染(ran)衣(yi)的仁(ren)祖(zu)(zu)對他所(suo)(suo)行的三跪九叩之(zhi)(zhi)禮,標志著朝(chao)(chao)(chao)鮮(xian)臣服(fu)于清朝(chao)(chao)(chao)(兩年后立(li)大(da)清皇帝功德(de)碑于此(ci)),史稱“丁丑下城(cheng)”。隨(sui)后,仁(ren)祖(zu)(zu)登上(shang)(shang)(shang)受(shou)(shou)降壇,坐在(zai)東(dong)側(ce),接受(shou)(shou)皇太極所(suo)(suo)賜(si)(si)酒肉,下壇后又穿(chuan)(chuan)上(shang)(shang)(shang)皇太極所(suo)(suo)賜(si)(si)的貂裘,再次謝恩,并命李景稷獻上(shang)(shang)(shang)明朝(chao)(chao)(chao)所(suo)(suo)頒國(guo)(guo)印。當天,許多朝(chao)(chao)(chao)鮮(xian)被俘男女看到(dao)仁(ren)祖(zu)(zu)后痛哭著說:“主(zhu)上(shang)(shang)(shang)何忍使(shi)吾輩至(zhi)此(ci)耶?朝(chao)(chao)(chao)廷士(shi)大(da)夫分黨交(jiao)爭,不恤(xu)國(guo)(guo)事,以至(zhi)于此(ci),而朝(chao)(chao)(chao)士(shi)之(zhi)(zhi)誤國(guo)(guo)者晏然如(ru)平昔,徒令無辜百姓受(shou)(shou)此(ci)系累之(zhi)(zhi)慘(can),愿主(zhu)上(shang)(shang)(shang)念之(zhi)(zhi),拯濟于水火之(zhi)(zhi)中矣!”仁(ren)祖(zu)(zu)目睹這一幕,“俯視流涕”。二月(yue)(yue)一日(ri),仁(ren)祖(zu)(zu)和百官返回漢城(cheng)。
二(er)月二(er)日(ri),皇太(tai)極(ji)班(ban)師歸(gui)國(guo),留下貝子碩讬(tuo)及三順王攻打皮島。皇太(tai)極(ji)在班(ban)師途中下令(ling)“勿得劫(jie)掠降(jiang)民”,但朝鮮方面有記載稱(cheng)清(qing)軍撤(che)退時“搶掠之患,甚(shen)于(yu)來時”。